9 Comments
User's avatar
Jan's avatar

Thanks for an interesting read. As a primary teacher I hugely valued oracy. Many very young children were able to express themselves in sophisticated ways well before they could do so in writing so taking note of oracy is important. I always included presentations as part of the curriculum and was often amazed at how kids who maybe struggled with writing could shine. Memorable was a Year 6 boy who chose to talk about his hobby, which was fishing. He brought his gear with him and spoke knowledgeably on the subject for the allocated time. The rest of the class were enthralled. I think one of the important criteria I'd add would be an awareness of audience. It's as important in oracy as in writing. I'm a spoken radio junkie and despair of the clichéd jabber that so many speakers, whether politicians, celebrities or presenters, use. Teachers might mark kids down for the repetitive use of 'so' or 'like' but adults pepper their speech with it even on the hallowed BBC. Another thought. I wonder might the results have been different if the students had been allowed a free choice of subject matter .

MICHAEL DAWSON's avatar

When I read the title, I did wonder if this post was going to be about the top third of pupils. As an outsider, my impression is that the system is already geared heavily to helping weaker pupils, rather than stretching the stronger ones - the vast sums being spent on SEND being only the most expensive example.

The correlation between oracy and written work is interesting. I know that a correlation coefficient of over 0.4 in social research is pretty high, but given the criteria the markers seem to have used - more or less what you'd use to mark written work as well - one might have expected the correlation to be even higher. That suggests two things to me:

1) Should the criteria for assessing oracy give more weight to other factors, such as fluency and pronunciation? I don't know what the formal criteria are and they may do this already.

2) Even with all assessors supposedly applying the same marking criteria, oracy is something that's inherently prone to subjective responses. Could a trained AI assess the same recordings gathered in this research to see how its marks would compare with the teachers'? I suspect that the resulting correlation coefficient with written work would be higher because AI would be more "reliable" (in the technical sense of being less prone to rating error).

Tom Sherrington's avatar

Thanks for this. Love the detail and examples. Super interesting.

Caroline Spearing's avatar

Interesting that the teachers aren’t measuring the things specific to oracy - eg confidence, audibility, pace, posture. Nor does response to questioning seem to have been included in the task.

Ben Rogers's avatar

Thanks for writing this Chris. I suppose the sample is too small (and you wouldn't have the code anyway) to see the impact of dyslexia? It's plausible that dyslexic students might be markedly better at speaking.

Andy Frayne's avatar

Perhaps the main contribution of this piece is that it challenges a rather comfortable assumption in education - that children who struggle in one area must have compensating strengths in another and of course there is no reason why this should be true.

One question is whether we are teaching oracy as a collection of valuable communication skills or whether we are presenting it as a solution to problems which have their origins elsewhere.

If a child lacks the knowledge to discuss a subject intelligently, more speaking opportunities won't necessarily solve that problem. If they lack vocabulary, they need to acquire vocabulary. If they cannot construct a coherent argument, they need to learn how arguments are constructed. If they cannot explain something because they don't understand it, they need to understand it.

Which brings us back to the importance of a knowledge-rich curriculum.

Oracy should be an emergent property of good teaching as well as something explicitly taught. Children should have interesting and substantial things to talk about, the vocabulary with which to discuss them, and the intellectual tools to construct and defend an argument - otherwise there is a danger that oracy becomes another educational initiative which focuses on the visible activity (speaking) rather than the underlying capabilities which make that activity worthwhile.

It could be interesting in seeing a study comparing the oracy of pupils with high and low levels of subject knowledge (comparing pupils from England and Wales?) It would help establish how much apparent speaking ability is attributable to general communication skills and how much depends on actually knowing what you are talking about. That seems to be a more useful question for education policy than simply asking whether pupils are being given enough opportunities to speak.

Jan's avatar

"Oracy should be an emergent property of good teaching as well as something explicitly taught. Children should have interesting and substantial things to talk about, the vocabulary with which to discuss them, and the intellectual tools to construct and defend an argument..."

Agreed. I wonder also whether teachers are aware that their own oral communication should act as a role model. This is perhaps more applicable in secondary phase education. Would teachers of subjects other than English consider that they have a role in developing the students' oracy? I'd return again to an understanding of audience. The restricted code that's used among friendship groups or families isn't always going to be appropriate in other situations. I often hear academics on TV or radio being asked to contribute to some ongoing debate and I'm surprised that they use language that sounds as if they're a teenager.

Andy Frayne's avatar

“I wonder also whether teachers are aware that their own oral communication should act as a role model”. For non-english (subject) secondary school teachers that’s a definite yes – it’s a good opportunity to outline the reasoning processes that explain how a conclusive idea is arrived at.

As for audience – yes they’re vital too. Addressing attendees at the CST Conference in October 2026 Ed Sec Lucy Powell’s speech was revealing. The immediate audience included big movers and shakers in educational circles – people who can influence oracy delivery.

Reading through the speechs’ transcript and separating two often conflated things in oracy assessment (performance and idea quality) shows Powell’s fluency, confidence, structure, rhetorical devices, engagement with the audience and the ability to make a speech memorable – the performance aspects – are all good.

However, the quality of the ideas, the reasoning behind them, the use of evidence and the ability to explain and defend a position – are lacking. For example:

She frequently uses the language of evidence without taking the audience through the evidence itself.

She says “All the evidence tells us how much the best start in life really matters."

Of course it does but that doesn't tell us which interventions work best to address a child’s shaky start, how large their effects are or how much confidence we should have in the proposed policies.

There’s plenty more in her speech that disappoints – which is a shame – and she blows the opportunity of role-modelling good oracy in front of influential people.

https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/education-secretary-speech-at-cst-conference-2026

Jan's avatar

"There’s plenty more in her speech that disappoints – which is a shame – and she blows the opportunity of role-modelling good oracy in front of influential people."

I'm afraid I find that to be true of most politicians' speeches.