Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dan Rogers's avatar

I’m finding this “debate” is coming up a lot in the discussions about the use of LLMs in education. A lot of people who are coming to my school to talk about these things, or books/articles I am reading referencing how they are going to change education (they will) seem to suggest that students will be able to access, format and essentially download knowledge so instantaneously via LLMs and such like, that our teaching will shift dramatically to more “skills based” tasks. I have found this borderline impossible to reason with as the skills that are being suggested we pivot to in the face of LLMs aren’t really possible without the students having at the very least a foundational knowledge level in the first place.

How can a student pick apart a piece of writing about a historical event that they haven’t produced themselves, without knowing about the events first, or having a strong enough level of vocabulary to examine it? The better they know the topic, the better their examination of it will be. These things take time to embed and there are few shortcuts to this, and I’m not sure that outsourcing the knowledge gain is especially possible or conducive to developing the skills we want our students to develop. LLMs will doubtlessly have a place in our education system - we’d be foolish not to use them - but I can’t help but think if we expect them to learn knowledge on behalf of the students that we will only serve to flatten the intellect of our students to society’s detriment.

Expand full comment
Jared Fox's avatar

Great article.

2 comments.

1.

I see curriculum trends in the US heading towards the skills acquisition focus highlighted. This looks like the creation of increasingly popular ‘portraits of a graduate,’ and work based learning / vocational programs so was interesting to see what’s happening across the pond. Some good lessons learned.

2.

I could also see how the content v skills debate applies to a teacher’s efficacy. Most of us know (and research supports) that the best teachers have a deep content understanding of their subject area. This expertise, in turn, (if we use your content acquisition leads to skills development premise) may allow them to be more effective pedagogues.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts