Really helpful piece. Like you, I think Alpha will probably fail but quite like experiments (especially if they are ones which families with a lot of other options are voluntarily entering into).
Two other thoughts I had:
1. One point people have made is that given Alpha costs c. $50k per child, it's of limited interest as it can't scale. So far in education we've not found great ways of converting more money to better performance (some state schools do as well as some of our top private schools). I don't think they will, but if Alpha did find a way of getting dramatically higher learning for that sum of money, that would have a bunch of societal implications.
2. To me, what Alpha looks like most is a bunch of people who've said traditional learning and knowledge is overrated - maybe because of AI, maybe because of something else - and they actually want to inculcate character/entrepreneurship/risk-taking etc. (hence they spend all the time doing the afternoon things, including the kids on social media stuff) which they value more and see to the key to success. Maybe some think traditional school actually inhibits this type of entrepreneurship. I think they're probably wrong here, and that the current breed of entrepreneurs actually benefited a lot from classic knowledge/learning (even if they think they don't), but it's not a fundamentally insane proposition, and Alpha looks quite like what you'd design if you'd believed that.
2.5 (One other possibility is that Alpha does succeed in turning out more entrepreneur/VC/leader types, but also has a much higher failure rate - maybe some people with $50k a year to spend would see that as acceptable!).
Really helpful piece. Like you, I think Alpha will probably fail but quite like experiments (especially if they are ones which families with a lot of other options are voluntarily entering into).
Two other thoughts I had:
1. One point people have made is that given Alpha costs c. $50k per child, it's of limited interest as it can't scale. So far in education we've not found great ways of converting more money to better performance (some state schools do as well as some of our top private schools). I don't think they will, but if Alpha did find a way of getting dramatically higher learning for that sum of money, that would have a bunch of societal implications.
2. To me, what Alpha looks like most is a bunch of people who've said traditional learning and knowledge is overrated - maybe because of AI, maybe because of something else - and they actually want to inculcate character/entrepreneurship/risk-taking etc. (hence they spend all the time doing the afternoon things, including the kids on social media stuff) which they value more and see to the key to success. Maybe some think traditional school actually inhibits this type of entrepreneurship. I think they're probably wrong here, and that the current breed of entrepreneurs actually benefited a lot from classic knowledge/learning (even if they think they don't), but it's not a fundamentally insane proposition, and Alpha looks quite like what you'd design if you'd believed that.
2.5 (One other possibility is that Alpha does succeed in turning out more entrepreneur/VC/leader types, but also has a much higher failure rate - maybe some people with $50k a year to spend would see that as acceptable!).
I totally agree re the experiment. Succeed or fail, we will all learn from it so it is worth watching closely!
"My take on this is that there are limits to how much children can learn through screens."
My take is also that there are limits to how much children can learn in two hours.
The AI can be all-powerful or super-sharp. The human brain, though, remains the same as ever and cannot accelerate at will.
As Woody Allen put it: “I took a speed-reading course and read War and Peace in twenty minutes. It involves Russia.”