Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Francesco Rocchi's avatar

"My take on this is that there are limits to how much children can learn through screens."

My take is also that there are limits to how much children can learn in two hours.

The AI can be all-powerful or super-sharp. The human brain, though, remains the same as ever and cannot accelerate at will.

As Woody Allen put it: “I took a speed-reading course and read War and Peace in twenty minutes. It involves Russia.”

Will Orr-Ewing's avatar

Like you, very pro-experimentation and will be watching their London plans closely.

Some other aspects of Alpha School I’m on my guard about:

1. The aesthetics are very Sir Anthony Seldon circa 2010 (write-on walls; random ‘learning hubs’; cushions everywhere). But worse as now interspersed with grim pandemic Zoom booths!

See pics here: https://nypost.com/2026/01/30/business/new-65k-private-school-uses-ai-to-teach-students-in-just-two-hours-a-day-in-silicon-valley-bid-to-shake-up-us-education/

2. The ‘gamification’ (i.e. bribing children to learn) strikes me as cynical, soulless and striverist

3. I agree about encouraging science of learning ppl but Alpha only seems to value knowledge insofar as it supports future learning: I have never seen any praise of x poem, y historical period or z work of art on its own intrinsic merits. But perhaps they’re there in individual schools.

26 more comments...

Ready for more?